As a devoted Real Madrid supporter, the biggest question heading into the 2025 season is clear: Who will replace Carlo Ancelotti?
With speculation about Ancelotti taking over the Brazil national team and Real Madrid’s recent struggles—crashing out of both the Champions League and Copa del Rey—the pressure to find a visionary leader is at an all-time high. Let’s break down the top contenders who could be sitting in the Bernabéu dugout next season
⚪ The Ancelotti Conundrum: End of an Era?
It’s no secret—Carlo Ancelotti has brought a sense of calm and winning mentality to Real Madrid, collecting trophies and maintaining squad harmony. But the 2024–25 campaign has been far from ideal. Injuries to key players like Éder Militão and Courtois, multiple El Clásico defeats to Barcelona, and Real Madrid’s lack of a natural striker (Mbappé is a wide forward, not a classic No. 9) have exposed the team’s vulnerabilities.
Amidst all this, Ancelotti’s rumored agreement with the Brazilian Football Confederation (CBF) casts doubt on his continuity at Real Madrid. If the Italian tactician does decide to part ways, here’s who might be next in line.
Xabi Alonso: The Prodigal Son Returns?
Currently making waves at Bayer Leverkusen, Xabi Alonso has quickly built a reputation as one of the brightest young managers in Europe. In 2024, he led Leverkusen to a historic Bundesliga title with an aggressive, yet balanced brand of football.
As a former midfield maestro at Real Madrid, Alonso understands the pressure, the politics, and the passion that comes with managing the club. His bond with the institution and his eye for youth development make him a natural successor. If Real Madrid want long-term stability, Xabi is arguably the top pick.
Zinedine Zidane: Could He Return… Again?
It almost feels poetic—Zidane returning when Real Madrid needs him most. After all, he led the club to three consecutive Champions League titles, something no manager has achieved in the modern era.
Zizou knows how to handle the egos, the expectations, and the press like very few do. He has always had the players’ trust, and his trophy haul speaks for itself. However, the question remains: does he want to return to the chaos, or is he eyeing the French national team instead?
Jürgen Klopp: The Charismatic Leader
Jürgen Klopp has openly mentioned his desire to take a sabbatical or move on after a long spell in England. His attacking, gegenpressing style could be a breath of fresh air at the Bernabéu.
.jpg?auto=webp&format=pjpg&width=3840&quality=60)
Imagine the intensity of a Klopp-led Real Madrid—with Vinícius Jr., Mbappé, and Bellingham pressing high and terrorizing defenses. But Klopp is also a strong personality, and it remains to be seen whether Real Madrid’s demanding culture would align with his values.
Roberto De Zerbi: Tactical Visionary
De Zerbi may not have the trophy cabinet of others on this list, but his work at Brighton and now elsewhere in Europe has impressed many top clubs. He’s known for possession-based, attacking football and a meticulous tactical approach.
Madridistas who crave beautiful football might find De Zerbi’s approach exciting. However, he lacks experience managing egos and expectations at a club the size of Real Madrid. He would be a high-risk, high-reward pick.
Raul Gonzalez: Club Legend in Waiting?
Raul, the former Galactico and current Real Madrid Castilla coach, is an internal option worth considering. He’s been quietly working with Madrid’s youth teams, understanding the club’s values and the next generation of talent.
Promoting from within has worked before (Zidane, anyone?), and Raul commands instant respect in the dressing room. However, the jump from Castilla to the first team is massive, and he may need more experience elsewhere before taking the main job.Wildcard Pick: Thomas Tuchel
Wildcard Pick: Thomas Tuchel
Yes, Thomas Tuchel may be a polarizing figure, but he’s available and proven. He won the Champions League with Chelsea and has managed top clubs like PSG and Bayern. His tactical flexibility and ability to adapt could serve Real Madrid well in transitional phases.
The downside? Tuchel tends to clash with management—a risky proposition given how political the Real Madrid boardroom can be.
Conclusion: Time for Real Madrid to Look Ahead
So, who will replace Carlo Ancelotti in 2025? There’s no easy answer. Each name brings strengths and potential risks. As a fan, I want someone who respects the club’s identity but isn’t afraid to evolve with the times.
Real Madrid is at a crucial juncture—with Barcelona leading the La Liga title race and still in all three competitions, and Madrid’s lack of a striker and recent El Clásico losses exposing weaknesses. The managerial decision will shape not just next season, but the next era.
❓What Do You Think?
-
- Should Madrid go for experience or embrace a bold, younger choice?
-
- Is Xabi Alonso ready for the top job?
-
- Could Zidane complete a historic third stint?
Let’s discuss in the comments!